Uncertainty and precaution in environmental management

Martin Paul Krayer von Krauss, M.B.A. van Asselt, Mogens Henze, J. Ravetz, M.B. Beck

    Research output: Contribution to journalConference articleResearchpeer-review

    Abstract

    In this paper, two different visions of the relationship between science and policy are contrasted with one another: the "modern" vision and the "precautionary" vision. Conditions which must apply in order to invoke the Precautionary Principle are presented, as are some of the main challenges posed by the principle. The following central question remains: If scientific certainty cannot be provided, what may then justify regulatory interventions, and what degree of intervention is justifiable? The notion of "quality of information" is explored, and it is emphasized that there can be no absolute definition of good or bad quality. Collective judgments of quality are only possible through deliberation on the characteristics of the information, and on the relevance of the information to the policy context. Reference to a relative criterion therefore seems inevitable and legal complexities are to be expected. Uncertainty is presented as a multidimensional concept, reaching far beyond the conventional statistical interpretation of the concept. Of critical importance is the development of methods for assessing qualitative categories of uncertainty. Model quality assessment should observe the following rationale: identify a model that is suited to the purpose, yet bears some reasonable resemblance to the "real" phenomena. In this context, "purpose" relates to the policy and societal contexts in which the assessment results are to be used. It is therefore increasingly agreed that judgment of the quality of assessments necessarily involves the participation of non-modellers and nonscientists. A challenging final question is: How to use uncertainty information in policy contexts? More research is required in order to answer this question.
    Original languageEnglish
    JournalWater Science and Technology
    Volume52
    Issue number6
    Pages (from-to)1-9
    ISSN0273-1223
    Publication statusPublished - 2005
    EventInternational Symposium on Uncertainty and Precaution in Environment Management - Copenhagen, Denmark
    Duration: 7 Jun 20049 Jun 2004

    Conference

    ConferenceInternational Symposium on Uncertainty and Precaution in Environment Management
    Country/TerritoryDenmark
    CityCopenhagen
    Period07/06/200409/06/2004

    Keywords

    • Environmental policy
    • Precaution
    • Precautionary principle
    • Uncertainty

    Fingerprint

    Dive into the research topics of 'Uncertainty and precaution in environmental management'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

    Cite this