Substitution between cars within the household

Bruno De Borger, Ismir Mulalic, Jan Rouwendal

    Research output: Contribution to journalJournal articleResearchpeer-review

    Abstract

    In this paper we study the demand for car kilometres in two-car households, focusing on the substitution between cars of different fuel efficiency in response to fuel price changes. We use a large sample of detailed Danish data on two-car households to estimate – for each car owned by the household – own and cross-price effects of increases in fuel costs per kilometre. The empirical results show that failure to capture substitution between cars within the household can result in substantial misspecification biases. Ignoring substitution, the basic model yielded fuel price elasticities of 0.98 and 1.41 for the primary and secondary cars, respectively. Accounting for substitution effects, these figures reduce to, respectively, 0.32 and 0.45. Consistent with substitution behaviour, we find that the fuel price elasticity of fuel demand exceeds the elasticity of kilometre demands with respect to the fuel price; the difference strongly increases at the highest deciles of the distribution of kilometre demand. Extending the model to account for driver heterogeneity and the role of car characteristics confirmed the relevance of substitution between cars within the household. We found strong evidence of substitution from the secondary to the primary car, especially if the latter is a more recent car with more horsepower. In general, the results of this paper emphasise the importance of behavioural differences related to the position of the most fuel efficient car in the household, suggesting that households’ fuel efficiency choices are related to their price sensitivity.
    Original languageEnglish
    JournalTransportation Research. Part A: Policy & Practice
    Volume85
    Pages (from-to)135–156
    ISSN0965-8564
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 2016

    Keywords

    • Fuel efficiency
    • Car use
    • Multiple car ownership
    • Substitution effects
    • Fuel consumption

    Cite this

    De Borger, Bruno ; Mulalic, Ismir ; Rouwendal, Jan. / Substitution between cars within the household. In: Transportation Research. Part A: Policy & Practice. 2016 ; Vol. 85. pp. 135–156.
    @article{e99fa053af1541d0a263908463ad1d43,
    title = "Substitution between cars within the household",
    abstract = "In this paper we study the demand for car kilometres in two-car households, focusing on the substitution between cars of different fuel efficiency in response to fuel price changes. We use a large sample of detailed Danish data on two-car households to estimate – for each car owned by the household – own and cross-price effects of increases in fuel costs per kilometre. The empirical results show that failure to capture substitution between cars within the household can result in substantial misspecification biases. Ignoring substitution, the basic model yielded fuel price elasticities of 0.98 and 1.41 for the primary and secondary cars, respectively. Accounting for substitution effects, these figures reduce to, respectively, 0.32 and 0.45. Consistent with substitution behaviour, we find that the fuel price elasticity of fuel demand exceeds the elasticity of kilometre demands with respect to the fuel price; the difference strongly increases at the highest deciles of the distribution of kilometre demand. Extending the model to account for driver heterogeneity and the role of car characteristics confirmed the relevance of substitution between cars within the household. We found strong evidence of substitution from the secondary to the primary car, especially if the latter is a more recent car with more horsepower. In general, the results of this paper emphasise the importance of behavioural differences related to the position of the most fuel efficient car in the household, suggesting that households’ fuel efficiency choices are related to their price sensitivity.",
    keywords = "Fuel efficiency, Car use, Multiple car ownership, Substitution effects, Fuel consumption",
    author = "{De Borger}, Bruno and Ismir Mulalic and Jan Rouwendal",
    year = "2016",
    doi = "10.1016/j.tra.2016.01.007",
    language = "English",
    volume = "85",
    pages = "135–156",
    journal = "Transportation Research. Part A: Policy & Practice",
    issn = "0965-8564",
    publisher = "Pergamon Press",

    }

    Substitution between cars within the household. / De Borger, Bruno; Mulalic, Ismir; Rouwendal, Jan.

    In: Transportation Research. Part A: Policy & Practice, Vol. 85, 2016, p. 135–156.

    Research output: Contribution to journalJournal articleResearchpeer-review

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Substitution between cars within the household

    AU - De Borger, Bruno

    AU - Mulalic, Ismir

    AU - Rouwendal, Jan

    PY - 2016

    Y1 - 2016

    N2 - In this paper we study the demand for car kilometres in two-car households, focusing on the substitution between cars of different fuel efficiency in response to fuel price changes. We use a large sample of detailed Danish data on two-car households to estimate – for each car owned by the household – own and cross-price effects of increases in fuel costs per kilometre. The empirical results show that failure to capture substitution between cars within the household can result in substantial misspecification biases. Ignoring substitution, the basic model yielded fuel price elasticities of 0.98 and 1.41 for the primary and secondary cars, respectively. Accounting for substitution effects, these figures reduce to, respectively, 0.32 and 0.45. Consistent with substitution behaviour, we find that the fuel price elasticity of fuel demand exceeds the elasticity of kilometre demands with respect to the fuel price; the difference strongly increases at the highest deciles of the distribution of kilometre demand. Extending the model to account for driver heterogeneity and the role of car characteristics confirmed the relevance of substitution between cars within the household. We found strong evidence of substitution from the secondary to the primary car, especially if the latter is a more recent car with more horsepower. In general, the results of this paper emphasise the importance of behavioural differences related to the position of the most fuel efficient car in the household, suggesting that households’ fuel efficiency choices are related to their price sensitivity.

    AB - In this paper we study the demand for car kilometres in two-car households, focusing on the substitution between cars of different fuel efficiency in response to fuel price changes. We use a large sample of detailed Danish data on two-car households to estimate – for each car owned by the household – own and cross-price effects of increases in fuel costs per kilometre. The empirical results show that failure to capture substitution between cars within the household can result in substantial misspecification biases. Ignoring substitution, the basic model yielded fuel price elasticities of 0.98 and 1.41 for the primary and secondary cars, respectively. Accounting for substitution effects, these figures reduce to, respectively, 0.32 and 0.45. Consistent with substitution behaviour, we find that the fuel price elasticity of fuel demand exceeds the elasticity of kilometre demands with respect to the fuel price; the difference strongly increases at the highest deciles of the distribution of kilometre demand. Extending the model to account for driver heterogeneity and the role of car characteristics confirmed the relevance of substitution between cars within the household. We found strong evidence of substitution from the secondary to the primary car, especially if the latter is a more recent car with more horsepower. In general, the results of this paper emphasise the importance of behavioural differences related to the position of the most fuel efficient car in the household, suggesting that households’ fuel efficiency choices are related to their price sensitivity.

    KW - Fuel efficiency

    KW - Car use

    KW - Multiple car ownership

    KW - Substitution effects

    KW - Fuel consumption

    U2 - 10.1016/j.tra.2016.01.007

    DO - 10.1016/j.tra.2016.01.007

    M3 - Journal article

    VL - 85

    SP - 135

    EP - 156

    JO - Transportation Research. Part A: Policy & Practice

    JF - Transportation Research. Part A: Policy & Practice

    SN - 0965-8564

    ER -