Industry 4.0 – A challenge for variation simulation tools for mechanical assemblies

Srinivasa M. Boorla*, Kristian Bjarklev, Tobias Eifler, Thomas J. Howard, Christopher A. McMahon

*Corresponding author for this work

Research output: Contribution to journalJournal articleResearchpeer-review

264 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Variation Analysis (VA) is used to simulate final product variation, taking into consideration part manufacturing and assembly variations. In VA, all the manufacturing and assembly processes are defined at the product design stage. Process Capability Data Bases (PCDB) provide information about measured variation from previous products and processes and allow the designer to apply this to the new product. A new challenge to this traditional approach is posed by the Industry 4.0 (I4.0) revolution, where Smart Manufacturing (SM) is applied. The manufacturing intelligence and adaptability characteristics of SM make present PCDBs obsolete. Current tolerance analysis methods, which are made for discrete assembly products, are also challenged. This paper discusses the differences expected in future factories relevant to VA, and the approaches required to meet this challenge. Current processes are mapped using I4.0 philosophy and gaps are analysed for potential approaches for tolerance analysis tools. Matching points of simulation capability and I4.0 intents are identified as opportunities. Applying conditional variations, incorporating levels of adjustability, and the un-suitability of present Monte Carlo simulation due to changed mass production characteristics, are considered as major challenges. Opportunities including predicting residual stresses in the final product and linking them to product deterioration, calculating non-dimensional performances and extending simulations for process manufactured products, such as drugs, food products etc. are additional winning aspects for next generation VA tools.
Original languageEnglish
JournalAdvances in Computational Design
Volume4
Issue number1
Pages (from-to)43-52
ISSN2466-0523
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2019

Keywords

  • Industry 4.0
  • Variation analysis
  • Monte Carlo
  • Conditional variation
  • Selective manufacturing

Cite this

@article{52910107051140d194e61f392c7ec998,
title = "Industry 4.0 – A challenge for variation simulation tools for mechanical assemblies",
abstract = "Variation Analysis (VA) is used to simulate final product variation, taking into consideration part manufacturing and assembly variations. In VA, all the manufacturing and assembly processes are defined at the product design stage. Process Capability Data Bases (PCDB) provide information about measured variation from previous products and processes and allow the designer to apply this to the new product. A new challenge to this traditional approach is posed by the Industry 4.0 (I4.0) revolution, where Smart Manufacturing (SM) is applied. The manufacturing intelligence and adaptability characteristics of SM make present PCDBs obsolete. Current tolerance analysis methods, which are made for discrete assembly products, are also challenged. This paper discusses the differences expected in future factories relevant to VA, and the approaches required to meet this challenge. Current processes are mapped using I4.0 philosophy and gaps are analysed for potential approaches for tolerance analysis tools. Matching points of simulation capability and I4.0 intents are identified as opportunities. Applying conditional variations, incorporating levels of adjustability, and the un-suitability of present Monte Carlo simulation due to changed mass production characteristics, are considered as major challenges. Opportunities including predicting residual stresses in the final product and linking them to product deterioration, calculating non-dimensional performances and extending simulations for process manufactured products, such as drugs, food products etc. are additional winning aspects for next generation VA tools.",
keywords = "Industry 4.0, Variation analysis, Monte Carlo, Conditional variation, Selective manufacturing",
author = "Boorla, {Srinivasa M.} and Kristian Bjarklev and Tobias Eifler and Howard, {Thomas J.} and McMahon, {Christopher A.}",
year = "2019",
doi = "10.12989/acd.2019.4.1.043",
language = "English",
volume = "4",
pages = "43--52",
journal = "Advances in Computational Design",
issn = "2466-0523",
publisher = "Techno-Press",
number = "1",

}

Industry 4.0 – A challenge for variation simulation tools for mechanical assemblies. / Boorla, Srinivasa M.; Bjarklev, Kristian; Eifler, Tobias; Howard, Thomas J.; McMahon, Christopher A.

In: Advances in Computational Design, Vol. 4, No. 1, 2019, p. 43-52.

Research output: Contribution to journalJournal articleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Industry 4.0 – A challenge for variation simulation tools for mechanical assemblies

AU - Boorla, Srinivasa M.

AU - Bjarklev, Kristian

AU - Eifler, Tobias

AU - Howard, Thomas J.

AU - McMahon, Christopher A.

PY - 2019

Y1 - 2019

N2 - Variation Analysis (VA) is used to simulate final product variation, taking into consideration part manufacturing and assembly variations. In VA, all the manufacturing and assembly processes are defined at the product design stage. Process Capability Data Bases (PCDB) provide information about measured variation from previous products and processes and allow the designer to apply this to the new product. A new challenge to this traditional approach is posed by the Industry 4.0 (I4.0) revolution, where Smart Manufacturing (SM) is applied. The manufacturing intelligence and adaptability characteristics of SM make present PCDBs obsolete. Current tolerance analysis methods, which are made for discrete assembly products, are also challenged. This paper discusses the differences expected in future factories relevant to VA, and the approaches required to meet this challenge. Current processes are mapped using I4.0 philosophy and gaps are analysed for potential approaches for tolerance analysis tools. Matching points of simulation capability and I4.0 intents are identified as opportunities. Applying conditional variations, incorporating levels of adjustability, and the un-suitability of present Monte Carlo simulation due to changed mass production characteristics, are considered as major challenges. Opportunities including predicting residual stresses in the final product and linking them to product deterioration, calculating non-dimensional performances and extending simulations for process manufactured products, such as drugs, food products etc. are additional winning aspects for next generation VA tools.

AB - Variation Analysis (VA) is used to simulate final product variation, taking into consideration part manufacturing and assembly variations. In VA, all the manufacturing and assembly processes are defined at the product design stage. Process Capability Data Bases (PCDB) provide information about measured variation from previous products and processes and allow the designer to apply this to the new product. A new challenge to this traditional approach is posed by the Industry 4.0 (I4.0) revolution, where Smart Manufacturing (SM) is applied. The manufacturing intelligence and adaptability characteristics of SM make present PCDBs obsolete. Current tolerance analysis methods, which are made for discrete assembly products, are also challenged. This paper discusses the differences expected in future factories relevant to VA, and the approaches required to meet this challenge. Current processes are mapped using I4.0 philosophy and gaps are analysed for potential approaches for tolerance analysis tools. Matching points of simulation capability and I4.0 intents are identified as opportunities. Applying conditional variations, incorporating levels of adjustability, and the un-suitability of present Monte Carlo simulation due to changed mass production characteristics, are considered as major challenges. Opportunities including predicting residual stresses in the final product and linking them to product deterioration, calculating non-dimensional performances and extending simulations for process manufactured products, such as drugs, food products etc. are additional winning aspects for next generation VA tools.

KW - Industry 4.0

KW - Variation analysis

KW - Monte Carlo

KW - Conditional variation

KW - Selective manufacturing

U2 - 10.12989/acd.2019.4.1.043

DO - 10.12989/acd.2019.4.1.043

M3 - Journal article

VL - 4

SP - 43

EP - 52

JO - Advances in Computational Design

JF - Advances in Computational Design

SN - 2466-0523

IS - 1

ER -