Implementation of the Blade Element Momentum Model on a Polar Grid and its Aeroelastic Load Impact

Research output: Contribution to journalJournal articleResearchpeer-review

28 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

We show that the up-scaling of wind turbines from rotor diameters of 15–20 m to presently large rotors of 150–200 m has changed the requirements for the aerodynamic Blade Element Momentum (BEM) models in the aeroelastic codes. This is because the typical scales in the inflow turbulence are now comparable with the rotor diameter of the large turbines. Therefore the spectrum of the incoming turbulence relative to the rotating blade has increased energy content on 1P, 2P, ..., nP and the annular mean induction approach in a classical BEM implementation might no longer be a good approximation for large rotors. We present a complete BEM implementation on a polar grid that models the induction response to the considerable 1P, 2P, ..., nP inflow variations, including models for yawed inflow, dynamic inflow and radial induction. At each time step in an aeroelastic simulation the induction derived from a local BEM approach is updated at all the stationary grid points covering the swept area so the model can be characterized as an engineering actuator disc (AD) solution. The induction at each grid point varies slowly in time due to the dynamic inflow filter but the rotating blade now samples the induction field; as a result the induction seen from the blade is highly unsteady and has a spectrum with distinct 1P, 2P, ..., nP peaks. The load impact mechanism from this unsteady induction is analyzed and it is found that the load impact strongly depends on the turbine design and operating conditions. For operation at low to medium thrust coefficients (conventional turbines at above rated wind speed or low induction turbines in the whole operating range) it is found that the grid BEM gives typically 8–10 % lower 1 Hz fatigue loads than the classical annular mean BEM approach. At high thrust coefficients the grid BEM can give slightly increased fatigue loads. In the paper the implementation of the grid based BEM is described in detail and finally several validation cases are presented.
Original languageEnglish
JournalWind Energy Science
Volume5
Pages (from-to)1-27
Number of pages27
ISSN2366-7443
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2020

Cite this

@article{cccd5b76384d4c95912f6cbf47cf7d6d,
title = "Implementation of the Blade Element Momentum Model on a Polar Grid and its Aeroelastic Load Impact",
abstract = "We show that the up-scaling of wind turbines from rotor diameters of 15–20 m to presently large rotors of 150–200 m has changed the requirements for the aerodynamic Blade Element Momentum (BEM) models in the aeroelastic codes. This is because the typical scales in the inflow turbulence are now comparable with the rotor diameter of the large turbines. Therefore the spectrum of the incoming turbulence relative to the rotating blade has increased energy content on 1P, 2P, ..., nP and the annular mean induction approach in a classical BEM implementation might no longer be a good approximation for large rotors. We present a complete BEM implementation on a polar grid that models the induction response to the considerable 1P, 2P, ..., nP inflow variations, including models for yawed inflow, dynamic inflow and radial induction. At each time step in an aeroelastic simulation the induction derived from a local BEM approach is updated at all the stationary grid points covering the swept area so the model can be characterized as an engineering actuator disc (AD) solution. The induction at each grid point varies slowly in time due to the dynamic inflow filter but the rotating blade now samples the induction field; as a result the induction seen from the blade is highly unsteady and has a spectrum with distinct 1P, 2P, ..., nP peaks. The load impact mechanism from this unsteady induction is analyzed and it is found that the load impact strongly depends on the turbine design and operating conditions. For operation at low to medium thrust coefficients (conventional turbines at above rated wind speed or low induction turbines in the whole operating range) it is found that the grid BEM gives typically 8–10 {\%} lower 1 Hz fatigue loads than the classical annular mean BEM approach. At high thrust coefficients the grid BEM can give slightly increased fatigue loads. In the paper the implementation of the grid based BEM is described in detail and finally several validation cases are presented.",
author = "{Aagaard Madsen}, Helge and Larsen, {Torben Juul} and Georg Pirrung and Ang Li and Frederik Zahle",
year = "2020",
doi = "10.5194/wes-2019-53",
language = "English",
volume = "5",
pages = "1--27",
journal = "Wind Energy Science",
issn = "2366-7443",
publisher = "Copernicus GmbH",

}

Implementation of the Blade Element Momentum Model on a Polar Grid and its Aeroelastic Load Impact. / Aagaard Madsen , Helge; Larsen, Torben Juul; Pirrung, Georg; Li, Ang; Zahle, Frederik.

In: Wind Energy Science, Vol. 5, 2020, p. 1-27.

Research output: Contribution to journalJournal articleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Implementation of the Blade Element Momentum Model on a Polar Grid and its Aeroelastic Load Impact

AU - Aagaard Madsen , Helge

AU - Larsen, Torben Juul

AU - Pirrung, Georg

AU - Li, Ang

AU - Zahle, Frederik

PY - 2020

Y1 - 2020

N2 - We show that the up-scaling of wind turbines from rotor diameters of 15–20 m to presently large rotors of 150–200 m has changed the requirements for the aerodynamic Blade Element Momentum (BEM) models in the aeroelastic codes. This is because the typical scales in the inflow turbulence are now comparable with the rotor diameter of the large turbines. Therefore the spectrum of the incoming turbulence relative to the rotating blade has increased energy content on 1P, 2P, ..., nP and the annular mean induction approach in a classical BEM implementation might no longer be a good approximation for large rotors. We present a complete BEM implementation on a polar grid that models the induction response to the considerable 1P, 2P, ..., nP inflow variations, including models for yawed inflow, dynamic inflow and radial induction. At each time step in an aeroelastic simulation the induction derived from a local BEM approach is updated at all the stationary grid points covering the swept area so the model can be characterized as an engineering actuator disc (AD) solution. The induction at each grid point varies slowly in time due to the dynamic inflow filter but the rotating blade now samples the induction field; as a result the induction seen from the blade is highly unsteady and has a spectrum with distinct 1P, 2P, ..., nP peaks. The load impact mechanism from this unsteady induction is analyzed and it is found that the load impact strongly depends on the turbine design and operating conditions. For operation at low to medium thrust coefficients (conventional turbines at above rated wind speed or low induction turbines in the whole operating range) it is found that the grid BEM gives typically 8–10 % lower 1 Hz fatigue loads than the classical annular mean BEM approach. At high thrust coefficients the grid BEM can give slightly increased fatigue loads. In the paper the implementation of the grid based BEM is described in detail and finally several validation cases are presented.

AB - We show that the up-scaling of wind turbines from rotor diameters of 15–20 m to presently large rotors of 150–200 m has changed the requirements for the aerodynamic Blade Element Momentum (BEM) models in the aeroelastic codes. This is because the typical scales in the inflow turbulence are now comparable with the rotor diameter of the large turbines. Therefore the spectrum of the incoming turbulence relative to the rotating blade has increased energy content on 1P, 2P, ..., nP and the annular mean induction approach in a classical BEM implementation might no longer be a good approximation for large rotors. We present a complete BEM implementation on a polar grid that models the induction response to the considerable 1P, 2P, ..., nP inflow variations, including models for yawed inflow, dynamic inflow and radial induction. At each time step in an aeroelastic simulation the induction derived from a local BEM approach is updated at all the stationary grid points covering the swept area so the model can be characterized as an engineering actuator disc (AD) solution. The induction at each grid point varies slowly in time due to the dynamic inflow filter but the rotating blade now samples the induction field; as a result the induction seen from the blade is highly unsteady and has a spectrum with distinct 1P, 2P, ..., nP peaks. The load impact mechanism from this unsteady induction is analyzed and it is found that the load impact strongly depends on the turbine design and operating conditions. For operation at low to medium thrust coefficients (conventional turbines at above rated wind speed or low induction turbines in the whole operating range) it is found that the grid BEM gives typically 8–10 % lower 1 Hz fatigue loads than the classical annular mean BEM approach. At high thrust coefficients the grid BEM can give slightly increased fatigue loads. In the paper the implementation of the grid based BEM is described in detail and finally several validation cases are presented.

U2 - 10.5194/wes-2019-53

DO - 10.5194/wes-2019-53

M3 - Journal article

VL - 5

SP - 1

EP - 27

JO - Wind Energy Science

JF - Wind Energy Science

SN - 2366-7443

ER -