An exploration of barriers for commercializing phosphorus recovery technologies

Bing Li*, Isuru A. Udugama, Seyed Soheil Mansouri, Wei Yu, Saeid Baroutian, Krist V. Gernaey, Brent R. Young

*Corresponding author for this work

Research output: Contribution to journalJournal articleResearchpeer-review

Abstract

Phosphorus is an essential element in sustaining modern day farming practices and is expected to deplete within the next 100 years. However, phosphorus utilisation efficiencies in most countries are below 20%, making the implementation of suitable phosphorus recovering technologies urgent and necessary. In spite of intensive research and development, there are only a few commercial recovery facilities being implemented. Therefore, there is a need to identify potential roadblocks/hurdles in a systematic manner. To this end, technology readiness level, process economics and sensitivity analyses were novelly integrated and employed to evaluate the opportunities and hurdles during the implementation of current phosphorus recovery technologies. The enhanced methodology is demonstrated via a case study, revealing that only struvite crystallization is sufficiently mature to be industrially implemented. Under most scenarios evaluated, struvite crystallization can be profitable or break-even if financial assistance is provided from policy-makers. Sensitivity analysis showed that overall profitability is highly sensitive to raw materials cost and product sale price, while phosphorus concentration in waste streams has less effect. Such an assessment could be extended to identify barriers in other resource recovery technologies.
Original languageEnglish
JournalJournal of Cleaner Production
Volume229
Pages (from-to)1342-1354
ISSN0959-6526
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2019

Keywords

  • Phosphorus recovery
  • Struvite crystallization
  • Technical readiness level
  • Net present value
  • Sensitivity analysis

Cite this

@article{7492dbafc8cb415488925e4dfb73ff61,
title = "An exploration of barriers for commercializing phosphorus recovery technologies",
abstract = "Phosphorus is an essential element in sustaining modern day farming practices and is expected to deplete within the next 100 years. However, phosphorus utilisation efficiencies in most countries are below 20{\%}, making the implementation of suitable phosphorus recovering technologies urgent and necessary. In spite of intensive research and development, there are only a few commercial recovery facilities being implemented. Therefore, there is a need to identify potential roadblocks/hurdles in a systematic manner. To this end, technology readiness level, process economics and sensitivity analyses were novelly integrated and employed to evaluate the opportunities and hurdles during the implementation of current phosphorus recovery technologies. The enhanced methodology is demonstrated via a case study, revealing that only struvite crystallization is sufficiently mature to be industrially implemented. Under most scenarios evaluated, struvite crystallization can be profitable or break-even if financial assistance is provided from policy-makers. Sensitivity analysis showed that overall profitability is highly sensitive to raw materials cost and product sale price, while phosphorus concentration in waste streams has less effect. Such an assessment could be extended to identify barriers in other resource recovery technologies.",
keywords = "Phosphorus recovery, Struvite crystallization, Technical readiness level, Net present value, Sensitivity analysis",
author = "Bing Li and Udugama, {Isuru A.} and Mansouri, {Seyed Soheil} and Wei Yu and Saeid Baroutian and Gernaey, {Krist V.} and Young, {Brent R.}",
year = "2019",
doi = "10.1016/j.jclepro.2019.05.042",
language = "English",
volume = "229",
pages = "1342--1354",
journal = "Journal of Cleaner Production",
issn = "0959-6526",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

An exploration of barriers for commercializing phosphorus recovery technologies. / Li, Bing; Udugama, Isuru A.; Mansouri, Seyed Soheil; Yu, Wei; Baroutian, Saeid; Gernaey, Krist V.; Young, Brent R.

In: Journal of Cleaner Production, Vol. 229, 2019, p. 1342-1354.

Research output: Contribution to journalJournal articleResearchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - An exploration of barriers for commercializing phosphorus recovery technologies

AU - Li, Bing

AU - Udugama, Isuru A.

AU - Mansouri, Seyed Soheil

AU - Yu, Wei

AU - Baroutian, Saeid

AU - Gernaey, Krist V.

AU - Young, Brent R.

PY - 2019

Y1 - 2019

N2 - Phosphorus is an essential element in sustaining modern day farming practices and is expected to deplete within the next 100 years. However, phosphorus utilisation efficiencies in most countries are below 20%, making the implementation of suitable phosphorus recovering technologies urgent and necessary. In spite of intensive research and development, there are only a few commercial recovery facilities being implemented. Therefore, there is a need to identify potential roadblocks/hurdles in a systematic manner. To this end, technology readiness level, process economics and sensitivity analyses were novelly integrated and employed to evaluate the opportunities and hurdles during the implementation of current phosphorus recovery technologies. The enhanced methodology is demonstrated via a case study, revealing that only struvite crystallization is sufficiently mature to be industrially implemented. Under most scenarios evaluated, struvite crystallization can be profitable or break-even if financial assistance is provided from policy-makers. Sensitivity analysis showed that overall profitability is highly sensitive to raw materials cost and product sale price, while phosphorus concentration in waste streams has less effect. Such an assessment could be extended to identify barriers in other resource recovery technologies.

AB - Phosphorus is an essential element in sustaining modern day farming practices and is expected to deplete within the next 100 years. However, phosphorus utilisation efficiencies in most countries are below 20%, making the implementation of suitable phosphorus recovering technologies urgent and necessary. In spite of intensive research and development, there are only a few commercial recovery facilities being implemented. Therefore, there is a need to identify potential roadblocks/hurdles in a systematic manner. To this end, technology readiness level, process economics and sensitivity analyses were novelly integrated and employed to evaluate the opportunities and hurdles during the implementation of current phosphorus recovery technologies. The enhanced methodology is demonstrated via a case study, revealing that only struvite crystallization is sufficiently mature to be industrially implemented. Under most scenarios evaluated, struvite crystallization can be profitable or break-even if financial assistance is provided from policy-makers. Sensitivity analysis showed that overall profitability is highly sensitive to raw materials cost and product sale price, while phosphorus concentration in waste streams has less effect. Such an assessment could be extended to identify barriers in other resource recovery technologies.

KW - Phosphorus recovery

KW - Struvite crystallization

KW - Technical readiness level

KW - Net present value

KW - Sensitivity analysis

U2 - 10.1016/j.jclepro.2019.05.042

DO - 10.1016/j.jclepro.2019.05.042

M3 - Journal article

VL - 229

SP - 1342

EP - 1354

JO - Journal of Cleaner Production

JF - Journal of Cleaner Production

SN - 0959-6526

ER -